This review may contain spoilers!
Wake Up Dead Man is the third film in Rian Johnson's Knives Out franchise. In this feature, a small-town parish comes under scrutiny after a leading member of the church is killed on the premises.
Something I always find really sharp about Rian Johnson's Knives Out scripts is that they hold a really clear mirror up to current society. Knives Out spoke to the class system and the all-consuming power of greed for wealth. Glass Onion has some interesting observations about society during lockdown, and more significantly, the deification of billionaires. Wake Up Dead Man uses a small town parish setting to highlight something happening on a much larger scale. The people within this parish are quite vulnerable, insecure and easy to manipulate and are steered by a figure in power to look down on others and turn against certain ideas and values. I like that this movie wasn't inherently blaming religion for this (though it did note institutional churches had a heavy hand to play), but speaks more that powerful figures prey upon the vulnerable and turn them against others. It gets right to the heart of why we have people screaming the word 'woke' in Facebook comments or a sharper push in right-wing ideology that has taken on a new, meaner edge to those who don't share their views. It's a complex theme to navigate objectively, and I found this feature does a really great job of presenting its case in the first act. The lead of this film, being a priest, Father Jud, who has done wrong in his life but found redemption through faith, is a very inspired choice. He has a decent chemistry with Blanc that is rather refreshing and a moral centre that will actually have you rooting for him while also leaving you guessing.
I absolutely adore how Rian Johnson finds an aesthetic within these films; each one has its own art style, and none have felt unsteady. This feature is quite gothic in some ways, with harsh shadows and the cold stone edges of an older church facade. This is a feature that plays with lighting creatively, be it capturing a figure by candlelight to the intense red of the flashback scenes. The editing is really tight, often feeling orchestrated with care. I also loved the score, how sinister and intriguing it can be while completely getting comedically obliterated by the soundtrack. 'Shimbleshanks, the Railway Cat' from the musical Cats gets a deserved honourable mention.
Daniel Craig, who played Benoit Blanc, is such a pivotal and iconic performance in these films; I love how he dashes about across this feature like a hound after a bone. Glenn Close, who played Martha Delacroix, is an absolutely inspired bit of casting; there is a scene Close delivers right near the end of the film that is one of the best scenes in the film. Josh Brolin, who played Mons. Jefferson Wicks, is an absolutely despicable and cruel figure here; Brolin is having a phenomenal run in 2025, and Wicks is just another top-level performance. Andrew Scott, who played Lee Ross, is a relatively interesting parasite of a character; Scott finds the simpering demeanour needed to find his character's place under the boot of Wicks. Daryl McCormack, who played Cy Draven, is that toxic need for attention and validation personified; McCormack is a sincerely wicked player bent on greed and power by the end of the film. Jeffrey Wright, who played Bp. Langstrom, is quite a nice subversion of a church leader; Wright has a sharp tongue and a quick wit in this.
However, the best performance came from Josh O'Connor, who played Fr. Jud Duplenticy. This is our guiding central protagonist for the film, and I found it very hard not to like him. O'Connor has a very easy charisma that feels sincere. Jud is a character with a very strong moral compass; he can get downright black and white at times and pretty righteous in his beliefs. O'Connor plays this figure well against the wilting and unusual personalities of the parish. I also found the way he grows excited and barrels into the case work to be quite intoxicating; O'Connor and Craig are dynamite together onscreen. Yet, he's not just this excitable young figure; there's an absolutely gorgeous scene where he supports someone over the phone through prayer that I think anyone would find quite moving. O'Connor is also really playing to the confusing, whirling conflict that is going on here; his character is set up and disputed as the killer multiple times. This is a character who finds himself very lost, so it is almost a breath of fresh air watching him grow so centred at the end.
This is a Knives Out universe film where the mystery sometimes feels a bit too convoluted for its own good. There are fake outs, resurrections, hallucinations, framed killers and a mysterious history to the setting, all flitting in and out of the central plot. This actually doesn't make the mystery very confusing; the killer is frankly quite an obvious suspect. It does, however, make the plot feel quite scattered at times. Wake Up Dead Man sometimes moves in a direction and then zags sharply in a whole other direction in a way that doesn't feel well-considered. The script for this feels like it needed to be tightened down further; the pacing also comes across as very scattered. The first act holds some of the most interesting content, but is also very slow in its delivery. I also felt that the wider ensemble cast just didn't impact the story in the same way other Knives Out franchise films did. Some of these roles were actually very boring and had nothing to add to the story at all, really. I also didn't feel Benoit was used especially well this time. In Wake Up Dead Man, we hear a lot about what Benoit doesn't know and why a thing is impossible, almost to defy our expectations artificially. It's a strange problem for a whodunnit film, but Benoit's ineptitude is almost a fabrication. The latter themes around religion and the truth behind it are about as deep as a couple of uni bros doing a philosophy paper, having a debate. I understand there had to be some deeper commentary around religion due to the setting, but I don't think any interesting material was actually struck.
Mila Kunis, who played Chief Geraldine Scott, is one of the more jarring performances in this film; Kunis feels entirely wrong for the role and style of film she is in. Jeremy Renner, who played Dr. Nat Sharp, gives quite a bland return to the screen; Renner is present in this film, but he gives absolutely nothing to this character. Kerry Washington, who played Vera Draven, is a character who is weirdly pushed to the background a lot; Washington masters self-righteous anger but is limited in her ability to seize the screen for herself. Cailee Spaeny, who played Simone Vivane, isn't even really much of a character performance at all; Spaeny is barely here, and you could've put anyone in that wheelchair and got the same effect. Thomas Haden Church, who played Samson Holt, is a bit too mundane and lacking in presence here; Church doesn't connect well with the rest of the cast and seems mainly positioned in this to die. Annie Hamilton, who played Grace Wicks, is the weakest part of a nice looking flashback scene; Hamilton is just two-dimensional, raving psychosis.
While not quite as mind-blowing as previous entries, Wake Up Dead Man is still one of the better films to grace our screens this year. I would give Wake Up Dead Man a 7.5/10.





