This review may contain spoilers!
Disclosure Day is a sci-fi thriller following a collection of people trying to bring out the truth about aliens and their first contact with humanity.
Steven Spielberg has found himself pretty synonymous with science fiction over the years; he has built a career on revolutionising the genre historically. His particular fascination with humanity having first contact with alien life translates directly into the material that he has worked with. E.T., Close Encounters of the Third Kind, War of the Worlds... even Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull bears his love for the traditional folklore of alien life interacting with humanity. Disclosure Day feels like a culmination of Spielberg's musings, or perhaps a final declaration of his personal fascination. This is a feature brimming with references to all the key ideas: abductions, psychic abilities, teleportation, crop circles, Roswell, UFOs and of course, little bug-eyed extraterrestrials. It's going to tick all the boxes for your everyday UFO sighting conspiracy theorist, which really should be a delight.
This is a film that works best when it's playing into the mystery and more clandestine elements of the feature. When Spielberg's blockbuster visuals pair with a high-speed chase sequence, or the impressive visual effects see our characters spring onto a train with moments to spare, that is when this film is sailing. It's when you are left with the question of who these characters are, how they're going to come together and if the information about aliens is going to come out. Spielberg and Koepp's most impressive feat of writing here is crafting a shadowy organisation antagonist that feels fresh. It's easy enough to have the secretive 'men in black', but positioning Firth's Scanlon as this sinister figure who can invade people's minds for interrogation and control took matters to another level. I genuinely think Colin Firth's turn as an extremely possessive and manic adversary, who looks to lose his fight across the feature, is the strongest performance we get.
While I have loved Spielberg all of my cinema-going life, I'm pretty clear he's far from immune to a misstep. As mentioned above, not all first contact stories he designs land (Crystal Skull). In a lot of ways, Disclosure Day struggles to work. The entire feature neither twists nor turns; it's exactly what it says on the box. People want to tell the world about aliens, and they do. Rarely are our characters particularly challenged to get to this end result. In fact, the protagonists are probably the weak aspect of this feature. Their journey often unfolds confusingly, littered with entertaining action sequences, possession scenes or humour. This film has a bizarre dual 'chosen ones' thing that plays out and gets relatively ridiculous. Watching Emily Blunt walk through a scene spouting streams of different languages, lines indicating telepathy, strange alien noises and gasping breaths as she 'snaps out of it' gets pretty goofy at times. In fact, it's Blunt's character that really takes all the nuance out of the feature for me. She seems to be a vessel for the pro-alien movement to find its voice. Yet her role is never challenged; there's no conflict here. Her powers open every door available to her.
This film also takes a bit of time out to have the 'Does alien life existing mean God isn't real?' debate. Which might work in a script that had the ability to discuss weightier themes. Eve Hewson plays Jane, a former nun initiate in the film, and her character seems primarily here to do two things: be possessed by Colin Firth and to ignite the aforementioned aliens = no God debate. The depth of this discussion doesn't really find its way past aliens existing doesn't necessarily mean God doesn't exist, and it only lands there due to some simple reassurances from Elizabeth Marvel's turn as a remarkably chill Catholic nun.
I like the idea of the truth being told; it's a principle that works very well as a theme. But the final act, folding one of the two protagonists, Kellner (O'Connor), squarely into a more diminished role, was an interesting choice. Josh O'Connor is one of the more interesting upcoming actors currently, but this is a role in which he really stumbles. I loved his initial mysterious hacker rebel, but as his character becomes enthralled in the psychic chosen one element, he loses his bearings. Colman Domingo, by comparison, is having a great turn as the leader of this underground movement. He plays a calm and measured guiding hand. I also adored Wyatt Russell as Emily Blunt's misguided musician boyfriend; he's a bit hapless but well-meaning.
This is a film that has all of Spielberg's late-career brushstrokes, for better or for worse. It's a visual feast for the eyes; prepared to play the past of an epic blockbuster, while also holding the audience with some really masterful frames. The psychic interrogation scene between Firth and Hewson might be the most visually inspired moment in the movie. I think the visual effects are often a treat too, though the CGI animals looked too animated to serve purpose. It's a rarity that I'm disappointed by a John Williams score, but here we are. When your film feels like a conspiracy thriller, and you have music that feels like it's from a 'kids on bikes' sci-fi feature from the 90s, you really feel the tonal disparity.
An impressive cast, a legendary filmmaker, all uniting around one of the weakest sci-fi scripts of the year. I would give Disclosure Day a 4/10.






