This review may contain spoilers!
Friendship follows Craig, a rather inept and lonely suburban Dad who finds his whole world changed when he makes friends with his neighbour, Austin. As Craig poorly navigates the world of adult friendships, we come to see his personal failings and poor character tarnish his life.
This is a fresh comedy from A24 that really leans on the brand of humour you will be accustomed to from Tim Robinson if you have seen his body of work. Scattered throughout this feature are wildly absurd scenes that feel like contained skits, blips of humour that will have you rolling. These moments of comedy might be camouflaged as a group of guy buds handing out before tilting into a perfectly rehearsed chorus rendition of 'My Boo' by Ghost Town DJs. Likewise, we get a classic American comedy drug trip scene, but this film makes me think of films like Booksmart in how it makes this moment unique. The protagonist quietly drifts into a Subway eatery, orders a sandwich from Paul Rudd and suddenly comes back to his senses an instant later. This movie is riddled with some wild points and sincerely fun comedy concepts.
This film is surprisingly sharp-looking for a comedy, transforming American suburbia into this insular and claustrophobic world that is Craig's life. I also have a real sweet spot for a comedy that uses its soundtrack for full punchline material; I mentioned 'My Boo', which steals the show, but putting Slipknot in for the punk rock stage was brilliant as well.
Paul Rudd, who played Austin, seems a little off the beaten path at times, but is clearly having fun here; Rudd really leans into the charming and charismatic aspects of his role keenly. Kate Mara, who played Tami, is probably playing this whole thing the most straight-edged, which works surprisingly well; Mara is a very sobering presence that counters Robinson's antics nicely. Billy Bryk, who played Tony, is a deceptively heavy hitter when it comes to comedy; Bryk gives us the toad scene, which is one of the best parts of the film. Josh Segarra, who played Devon, is in a fairly two-dimensional role, but he fills it very notably; Segarra just has to be the most captivating person in the room for a moment, and it works perfectly. Conner O'Malley, who played Patton, played a small role that stole the show for me; O'Malley turns a small interaction between himself and Robinson into the most side-splitting interaction of the feature.
However, the best performance came from Tim Robinson, who played Craig. This film is almost exclusively built around Robinson's brand of comedy so there is little surpise he shines the best within that. This is an off-kilter character who wanders away from good intentions at every turn in favour of his own self-interest. Robinson builds a good gag here around making Craig a sort of 'everyman'. We could bump into this guy on the street easily, and the humour lies in watching this everyman figure alight his whole life so easily. Robinson is a loud, destructive force who can play with jokes that subvert expectations or aim to make the viewer uncomfortable. I like how clear it was that his character was a complete narcissist who would happily toast his chances at a good life for one single second of self-satisfaction. A bizarre and captivating time from Robinson.
The moments where we get to sit in the comedy are great, but they're so brief and often swallowed by long sweeping moments of discomfort. This film is hooked around a character who is quite bad at being a husband and a father, he feels immense dissatisfaction and loneliness in his own life. You might think the 'friendship' element that is so titular might be the hinge on which this film swings for dealing with that. But not so! After a brief, failed stint at making friends, Craig just impulsively torches his life. We get an over-the-top comedic figure who is innately unlikable, marching through scenes, blowing up his life. He's a jerk, people don't like him, and the rest of the supporting characters aren't exactly underdogs worth rooting for either. This film basically generally points at middle-aged middle-class guys and says you're the problem, and then fails to evoke much more substance than that. It's a perfectly fine comedic theme, there are some good jokes, but the story and characters presented aren't easy to connect with. I also felt really pushed to the edge of my comfort levels when Craig started chewing on soap or when his teenage son kissed his mother on the lips; it felt like an attempt to be provocative just for the sake of it. There may have been a push for this to fit the A24 portfolio in terms of narrative style more than there needed to be.
The way this film is edited sets a sluggish pace that really ambles us along, considering how energetic Robinson can be; this is quite surprising. I also didn't like some of the circle wipes and other dated transitional effects that were scattered throughout. The score for the film was downright wild tonally. There was this low-toned chorus that sang across several scenes that didn't work for me. I felt like the score was intended to paint this film as a little more thought-provoking than it actually managed to be.
Jack Dylan Grazer, who played Steven, doesn't really serve much purpose here; I found he didn't play his part for comedy, and he added nothing to the overall story.
A phenomenal cast and some skit-like moments of hilarity don't salvage a film that is too busy trying to make you uncomfortable and unsettled. I would give Friendship a 4.5/10.